The example of Jon at the beginning of this article absolutely breaks my heart. I hate seeing readers struggling, but especially in front of their peers and on the spot like that. Poor Jon was probably very nervous. I also don’t agree that this style of popcorn reading encourages students to pay attention and remain on-task because there were plenty of times in elementary school that I would be listening and not following along, but I could make a pretty good guess as to where we were in the story. I would mainly be found tuning out the other students who were reading while I was reading ahead. It is also heartbreaking to read that students like Jon are given such hard reading materials when their reading level can’t support it. And having these students complete worksheets or writings about their reading when they can’t finish the reading, much less comprehend it, is pure torture.
This article makes me realize just how important finding students’ instructional reading level and texts that are on that level. Just like we learned in Dr. Schlagal’s Block 1 reading class, the instructional level texts are important for students to read in order to build fluency, comprehension, word recognition automaticity, as well as a love for reading. During my Block 1 internship, I saw my cooperating teacher finding books for students that they enjoyed reading and that were also on their instructional reading level. The students in the class seemed to like reading, but didn’t like to be required to do it for homework. In my Block 2 internship classroom, I see a lot of struggling readers. Mrs. Hogan says there are many of the fifth grade students on as low as a first grade reading level. They are starting a new reading program at the school in hopes that it will help these struggling readers, but I’m starting to think that just finding students literature on their reading level might help these issues as well. I don’t know for sure that these students aren’t given texts on their reading level because I haven’t been able to observe long enough to know, but from what I have read and been taught, I can see where this could greatly improve reading for these students.
I think connecting children’s literature to other content strands, such as social studies, is a great idea (and so does Dr. Frye!), but I am also sure that it doesn’t do any good if the reading material is too hard for the students to read. I do have one question though: How can you give students different reading material at different reading levels but still be able to bring it all together to learn about Native Americans or slavery?
Well, if I had just continued reading a little further, I would have answered my own question. As an example used in the article, students can be studying the Civil War and there are different books on different grade levels that students can read. I think a good idea for the classroom would be for students in these groups to discuss what they have learned about the Civil War from their books. Then maybe a class discussion on what all students have learned about the Civil War while using examples from their books for evidence could help bring about new aspects of the topic that other groups hadn’t experienced or thought of. This type of reading could also bring in certain aspects of the sustained silent reading that we read about earlier in the semester. Students could read their books silently, be paired off or grouped off with students who are reading other books, and discuss what they have found out or learned about a certain topic. I agree with the article when it says that student-led discussions are enjoyable to participate in and can help students better comprehend what they had read. I always felt in school, and even now, that if we have student-led discussions I can talk to my peers and they can clarify something that I didn’t understand or may have misunderstood. I think this is a great way for students to better comprehend and understand their readings and to also encourage them to actually read so that they will have something to contribute to the discussion. These types of student-led discussions can also hold students accountable for completing their readings.
I love that this article includes a list of books we can use with our future students on many grade levels! I was almost in stress-out mode when reading this article because I was wondering where on earth I was going to be able to find books about the same topic on different reading levels and how I might connect these books together. These lists really help me to feel better about finding books for my students and getting them interested in reading.
I can’t wait to start assessing the students in my fifth grade class to see what reading levels they are on so that I can hopefully point them in the direction of good books on their levels for their silent reading and individual reading time! I think it will be a great experience to connect these students to reading and hopefully help them improve their reading skills over the course of this semester and the time that I will spend with them.
“No one has ever seen a ‘first-grade class,’ or a ‘fifth-grade class.’ What a teacher should ‘see’ is a group of individuals, unique unto themselves. Not until differences are ‘seen’ is the teacher ready to teach, because learning the child must precede teaching him…” –Betts